Use one column for what the seller says, one for what the images show and one for what a try-on or a test must establish. A listing may call a shell waterproof, and a photo may show taped seams. Keep the performance claim separate until you see relevant test evidence. Use the Fashionreps jacket catalogue for practice with available listings and inspection images.
Keep the photo and the stated claim in separate cells. If an answer identifies a different size, fabric or model, save it as a separate record.
A worked example: did the reply close the jacket question?
The following is a fictional record, not a report about a seller or a tested jacket. A buyer asks whether a navy size M jacket has a chest width of 58 cm when zipped and laid flat. The reply says, “Size M should fit you.” That answer describes an opinion about fit; it does not supply the requested dimension.
Separate the request into observable fields
| Field | What would close it? |
|---|
| Selected variant | A readable note identifying navy, size M and the listing version. |
| Measurement object | The jacket itself, zipped and relaxed, rather than a body-size chart. |
| Measurement endpoints | A flat front photograph showing the tape from one underarm edge to the other. |
| Unit and result | A readable unit and reported value; the photograph and reply should agree. |
If only a shoulder close-up arrives, retain it as evidence about the shoulder. Leave the chest-width question open. A new attachment is not automatically an answer to the original question.
Write a follow-up that preserves the context
For this fictional example: “Thank you. My unanswered question concerns the chest width of the selected navy M, zipped and laid flat. Please show both tape endpoints and the unit, or tell me if this cannot be measured. Please confirm any fee before proceeding.” Do not paste a private order number into a public comment to make the example look more convincing.
Record a result without overstating it
Use three distinct outcomes: answered by the supplied evidence; still unanswered; or conflicting evidence. If a text reply reports 58 cm but the image cannot be read, record the text as a reported measurement and the image as unreadable. Do not average two conflicting values or turn a seller's fit opinion into a verified measurement.
This worksheet checks whether a response addresses a question. It cannot certify authenticity, long-term durability, comfort, or future delivery. Reopen the record if the colour, size, listing version or measurement method changes. Keep the original question, dated response and remaining uncertainty together.
Editorial worksheet updated 19 November 2026. Examples above are fictional; no independent product testing is claimed.